Shayn Herndon Lex Rachael Evelyn Sam Neil Bell Bree Bertie Gregory Detective Milo Manheim Mike Ajit Kelkar Henry Meg Donnelly Helicopter Pilot Malachi Barton Book Store Ghost Freya Skye Emergency Room Doctor Kylee Russell The Haunting of Kilahuna Narrator (voice) (as Brandon B. Graham) Emma Stone Billie Jean King Steve Carell Bobby Riggs Andrea Riseborough Marilyn Barnett Sarah Silverman Gladys Heldman Bill Pullman Jack Kramer Elisabeth Shue Priscilla Riggs Alan Cumming Ted Tinling Austin Stowell Larry King Eric Christian Olsen Lornie Kuhle Natalie Morales Rosie Casals Lewis Pullman Larry Riggs Jessica McNamee Margaret Court Martha MacIsaac Jane 'Peaches' Bartkowicz Wallace Langham Henry Mark Harelik Hank Greenberg Fred Armisen Rheo Blair Chris Parnell DJ John C. McGinley Herb Mickey Sumner Valerie Ziegenfuss Bridey Elliott Julie Heldman James Mackay Barry Court Tim Ransom Jerry Perenchio Chip Chinery Roone Arledge Cooper J. Friedman Bobby Riggs Jr. Bob Stephenson Bobby's Publicist Tom Kenny Bob Sanders